Timothy B. Schmit’s journey with The Eagles started just as the band was teetering on the brink of disintegration. Yet, in the midst of tension, Schmit’s first contribution to the band, “I Can’t Tell You Why,” became a smash hit. This R&B-infused ballad not only showcased Schmit’s vocal talents but also marked a pivotal moment in the Eagles’ evolution. But as quickly as success came, so did the band’s decline. Here’s the story behind one of the Eagles’ most memorable songs.
